Skip to content

The Platform: Sean Plunket & Ani O’Brien on the Mahuta family influence – UPDATE (Twice)


See at end of post for update

May 27,2022

The Platform follows up this story, first documented on The Daily Examiner see here and here. Both articles were bylined Victoria O’Brien. In addition there is an Opinion piece on the Platform; plus this item from Tuesday.

Sean Plunket followed that coverage with an interview and discussion with former Deputy PM and Foreign Minister Winston Peters. Much of what Peters said I agreed with, a rare occurrence.

Today we had this. Note major media outlets, with the exception of limited coverage in NZ Herald, have yet to give any coverage to this story. (UPDATE see below)

Again I reiterate the point I made the other day:

Back when John Key was PM, there was a great hollering and screeching about Judith Collins having contact with Oravida on a trip to China, her husband was/ is a director. Collins resigned as a Minister, but was subsequently brought back when she was cleared of wrongdoing. The hollering and screeching came from the left and the media. Strangely quiet at this time. Do I detect dual standards? Is there the stench of hypocrisy?

As previously, questions that need addressing, by the various parties, include, but are not limited to:

1 Did Mahuta comply fully, both as to the spirit as well as the letter of Cabinet Manual requirements

2 Were any hand offs by Mahuta to appropriate persons? Who determined the appropriateness of the hand off?

3 Are the Mahuta family members appointed to boards, working parties, consultancies appropriately qualified for those roles? Who reviewed the qualifications? Was the reviewer appropriately experienced and independent?

4 Is it appropriate that relatives of a Minister play key roles in areas that fall within major areas of that Minister’s responsibility? I would suggest not? Is it appropriate that the spouse/partner of a Minister or senior official should provide consulting services to the government of which his/her spouse/partner is a Minister or senior official?

5 Is it appropriate that one family should appear to have such a disproportionate influence?

6 Should one family member, no matter how competent, hold multiple roles eg Mahuta’s sister?

7 What was the appointment process followed for each role or activity? Did the process comply with best practice?

8 Were the appointments competitive? Where the appointments involved consultancy were others asked to tender? On what basis was the successful party selected?

9 Was any party consulted for advice on any of the matters encompassed by the questions above, or indeed on any aspect of the Mahuta clan appointments/involvements? If not, why not – given the circumstances and the probability that perception, if not reality might be negative? If yes, which third parties were consulted? Why were those parties chosen for consultation? What was the nature of the advice, if any, given?

10 Specifically, was the Cabinet Office consulted? If not, why not? what was the nature of their advice if any?

11 Was any advice sought from the Prime Minister or her staff? What was the nature of the advice sought? What was the content of the advice given?

12 Why has the MSM not taken any apparent interest in this story, especially given their reaction to Judith Collins Oravida visit, and the massive involvement of the Mahuta clan in matters within the Minister’s purview?

13 Is there any evidence that receiving monies from the Public Interest Journalism Fund has caused MSM to withhold comment?

14 Given the nature of the various matters raised should the appointment of an independent party to review the issue be an essential consideration? If an independent party with broad terms of reference is not appointed, what is the reasoning for such an appointment not being made.

The above list may well need expansion. Indeed the list has been expanded since first drafted to reflect further consideration.

UPDATE May 28,2022

In the post yesterday I mentioned coverage by NZ Herald, but late Friday I found this

So NZ Herald is credited by Newshub. Silly me, I thought Newshub employed journalists.


UPDATE for Correction see below – 29 May 2022

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: